Workplace Advisory & Compliance
When workplace standardisation becomes disability discrimination: lessons from the million-dollar Boroondara decision
A case-led briefing on separating the genuine requirements of a job from the employer's preferred method of performing it, and on the consultation that reasonable adjustment requires.

Key points
- In Norton v Boroondara CC [2026] VCAT 761 the Tribunal found the council directly discriminated under s 18 of the Equal Opportunity Act 2010 (Vic) when it dismissed a Local Laws Officer on the incorrect basis that no reasonable adjustment could enable him to perform the genuine and reasonable requirements of his role.
- A uniform fleet, roster, equipment or procurement standard is a method of doing the work; the legal question is whether the employee can perform the genuine requirements of the job with reasonable adjustment, not whether they can use the employer's preferred standard.
- Compensation was assessed at $901,163.03 under alternative orders (past and future income and superannuation plus $35,000 for non-economic loss), with reinstatement, interest and costs left open, so total exposure could exceed $1 million — a different order of exposure from the Fair Work Commission's unfair dismissal compensation cap. No $1 million award or payout was made.
- The Tribunal held that repeated show-cause letters threatening termination were not meaningful consultation; adjustment is a product of proper consultation, not unilateral decision-making by either party.
- The limits still apply, expressed in the language of the relevant statute: under the Victorian Act the duty is to make adjustments that are reasonable under s 20, with the s 23 exception where the genuine and reasonable requirements still cannot be performed, as the contrasting outcome in Muller v Toll Transport illustrates.
- Apparently routine operational decisions — a fleet standardisation, a rostering rule, an equipment specification — can create major contingent liability and warrant board-level and insurance attention.
A standard vehicle, a dismissal and a $901,163.03 assessment
What the Tribunal actually decided
The vehicle was a method, not the job requirement
Consultation is not a show-cause process
How Norton compares with Panazzolo and Muller
| Decision | Statutory basis | The requirement in issue | What the employer did | Outcome |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Norton v Boroondara CC [2026] VCAT 761 (15 September 2026) | Equal Opportunity Act 2010 (Vic) ss 18, 20, 23 | Extensive driving for a Local Laws Officer; the employer treated its standard i30 as the requirement | Repeated ergonomic and medical assessment of the same two vehicles, three show-cause processes, no trials, search confined to the existing fleet | Direct discrimination under s 18; s 23 exception not established; compensation assessed at $901,163.03 under alternative orders, with reinstatement, interest and costs left open |
| Panazzolo v Don's Mechanical and Diesel Service Pty Ltd [2023] FedCFamC2G 665 (2 August 2023) | Disability Discrimination Act 1992 (Cth) ss 5(2), 15(2); unjustifiable hardship under s 11 | Diesel mechanic duties following a fractured left ulna, with lifting and gripping restrictions | Required a full unrestricted medical clearance before any return, although a staged return, existing mechanical aids and co-worker assistance were available | Unlawful discrimination declared; $10,000 general damages, $30,000 for economic loss and $4,000 interest, totalling $44,000; costs left to a later application |
| Muller v Toll Transport Pty Ltd (2) (Human Rights) [2014] VCAT 472 (24 April 2014) | Equal Opportunity Act 2010 (Vic) ss 8, 20 | Allocation of delivery runs; a driver with Crohn's disease sought the return of a former run, saying the work he was given aggravated his condition | Learned of the disease only in November 2011; confirmed that extra toilet stops and consequent delays were acceptable; could not restore a run already allocated to another driver under the operative industrial agreement; the driver proposed no other adjustment and led almost no medical evidence about his needs | Application dismissed; no contravention of s 8 or s 20 established |
Where the lawful boundary sits
Why the exposure was so large
A defensible adjustment process
Governance, insurance and board oversight
What employers should do now
Sources and legal basis
How AWS can help
Reasonable adjustment checklist
- Describe the role functionally: what outcomes must be achieved, to what standard and how often, separately from the equipment, roster, vehicle or location currently used.
- Identify which requirements are genuinely essential and which are the organisation's chosen method, and record the reasoning.
- Acknowledge the request in writing, explain the process and confirm that no capacity or disciplinary process is being commenced by it.
- Seek medical information directed to function and to the specific duties, with the duties accurately described to the practitioner.
- Invite the employee's own proposals and record them, without requiring the employee to identify a complete solution.
- Search beyond the current arrangement, including options that could be acquired, leased or configured, not only what is already held.
- Obtain real cost, availability and operational evidence for each option considered, rather than relying on assertions about fitness for purpose.
- Consider a trial or a time-limited adjustment where the effect of an option cannot be assessed on paper.
- Record why each rejected option was rejected, on what evidence and by whom.
- Keep consultation about adjustments separate from any show-cause or capacity correspondence, and do not run the two together.
- Coordinate with any workers compensation claim, return-to-work plan or safety obligation rather than running parallel processes on different assumptions.
- Check employment practices or management liability notification obligations early where a dispute may become a claim.
- Escalate an unresolved adjustment dispute to a decision-maker outside the line before any capacity decision proceeds.
- Document the final decision, the requirements relied on, the adjustments considered and the reasons, at the time the decision is made.
Frequently asked questions
- Does a uniform policy applied to everyone avoid discrimination?
- No. Applying the same requirement to everyone is not in itself a defence. Under the Equal Opportunity Act 2010 (Vic), a requirement, condition or practice that disadvantages people with an attribute and is not reasonable may be indirect discrimination, and the person imposing it bears the burden of proving reasonableness. Separately, a decision made on the basis of an attribute — such as dismissing someone because of the effects of a disability — may be direct discrimination. In Norton the council's standard vehicle decision was lawful in itself; the contravention arose from how it dealt with the employee's request for an adjustment and from its conclusion that no adjustment was possible.
- How is a genuine requirement of the job different from the employer's method?
- The requirement is the outcome or function the role must deliver. The method is the particular way the employer currently achieves it. In Norton the requirement was safe and efficient travel across the municipality to carry out local laws duties; the Hyundai i30 was the employer's chosen means of achieving it. The Tribunal observed that the main function of a vehicle is safe conveyance and that a different vehicle with slightly different dimensions is not rendered unsuitable merely because the employer had assigned particular vehicle types to particular roles. Employers should write down the functional requirement before assessing capacity, and test whether a variation in method would still deliver it.
- Is a show-cause process improper when an employee has a disability?
- A show-cause process is a legitimate tool in its place. What the Tribunal rejected was using repeated termination threats as the vehicle for exploring adjustments. It described issuing show-cause letters threatening termination as not part of a meaningful negotiation or consultation process aimed at keeping a long-serving employee with a good record in employment. Consultation about adjustments and a formal capacity process are different activities: complete genuine consultation first, record what was explored, and only then consider whether a capacity decision is genuinely open.
- Does the employee have to nominate the exact adjustment?
- The employee must raise their needs — an employer is not a mind reader — but the Tribunal held the obligation is not one-sided. It said an employee cannot be expected to serve up the perfect adjustment without assistance and encouragement from the employer, and declined to hold the applicant's case against him for not naming an exact make and model. Practically, the employer should invite proposals, supply accurate duty information, investigate options itself and consider trials rather than waiting for a fully formed solution to arrive.
- Can an employer limit its search for adjustments to what it already owns or leases?
- Not automatically. In Norton the Tribunal observed that the process never needed to be limited to vehicles already in the council's fleet, and that with the size of leasing catalogues the conclusion that no suitable vehicle existed was illogical. The correct approach is to obtain real cost and operational evidence about the options actually available, including those that could be acquired, and to assess feasibility and hardship on that evidence rather than on the convenience of the existing arrangement.
- Why can discrimination compensation exceed the unfair dismissal cap?
- Unfair dismissal compensation under the Fair Work Act is capped, and compensation for shock, distress and humiliation is excluded. Discrimination jurisdictions are not built that way. Section 125 of the Equal Opportunity Act 2010 (Vic) allows the Tribunal to order an amount it thinks fit to compensate for loss, damage or injury suffered in consequence of the contravention, which can include future economic loss over many years and general damages. In Norton the future income and superannuation components made up the large majority of the $901,163.03 assessed under the alternative orders. This scale reflects a long-serving employee near the end of his working life with poor re-employment prospects; it is not the automatic consequence of every adjustment failure.
- When is an employer entitled to say no adjustment is available?
- When, on properly obtained evidence, the employee genuinely cannot perform the requirements of the role and no adjustment the statute requires would change that. Under the Victorian Act the question is whether the adjustments sought are reasonable within s 20 and, if the employee still could not adequately perform the genuine and reasonable requirements of the role, whether the s 23 exception applies. Under the Commonwealth Disability Discrimination Act, s 21A addresses inability to carry out inherent requirements even with reasonable adjustments, subject to its terms and exclusions. Section 21B separately provides an unjustifiable hardship exception, with the assessment and burden of proof governed by s 11. The two frameworks use different language and should not be merged. The distinction in practice is evidential: a conclusion reached after functional medical information, accurate duty analysis, consultation, genuine investigation of options and costed assessment will be defensible in a way that a conclusion reached by assumption will not.
- What should a board or insurer be told about a decision like this?
- Operational decisions that look minor can carry disproportionate contingent liability. Where an adjustment dispute is escalating toward capacity action, it is prudent to check notification obligations under employment practices or management liability cover early, because late notification can prejudice cover, and to give the matter visibility at the level that would be accountable for the exposure. Confirm the terms of the relevant policy with the broker or insurer rather than assuming cover.
Discuss this matter with AWS
Briefings can be scoped on a confidential basis. We respond within two business days.
Contact AWSRelated briefings
Workplace Advisory & Compliance
How to conduct a wage compliance review
An end-to-end guide for employers on governing, scoping, calculating, verifying and acting on a wage compliance review.
Read briefing →Workplace Advisory & Compliance
How to determine award coverage and classification
Coverage, application and classification are three separate questions, and job titles, salaries and payroll codes answer none of them. A step-by-step method for reaching a position you can stand behind.
Read briefing →Workplace Advisory & Compliance
Preparing for enterprise bargaining: an employer's roadmap
Making a single-enterprise agreement is a statutory process with fixed steps and deadlines. This roadmap follows the pathway from scoping and notification time through to approval and payroll implementation.
Read briefing →