Workplace Advisory & Compliance
Genuine redundancy: consultation, redeployment and documentation risks
Redundancy, genuine redundancy and redundancy pay answer different questions. This guide sets out the decision and evidence system behind a proposed redundancy — operational analysis, instrument mapping, consultation, redeployment, lawful selection, entitlements and record integrity.

Key points
- Redundancy, genuine redundancy under section 389 and redundancy pay are three separate questions with different tests and different evidence.
- Section 389 is a jurisdictional exclusion in unfair dismissal only; it does not answer general-protections, discrimination, instrument, contract or entitlement claims.
- The test focuses on the job, not the title or the incumbent — duties may continue and be redistributed, and relabelling a continuing job does not establish redundancy.
- Section 389(1)(b) concerns consultation obligations in an applicable modern award or enterprise agreement; other contractual, policy or statutory obligations are separate.
- Redeployment requires an evidenced search for identified roles or other work across the enterprise and associated entities, assessed against the individual's circumstances.
- Current FWC guidance indicates selection is not relevant to the genuine-redundancy test, but unlawful selection can support general-protections or discrimination claims.
Three different questions: redundancy, genuine redundancy and redundancy pay
The three-part test in section 389, and its limited effect
Defining the job and the operational change
Instrument mapping and consultation timing
A decision and evidence matrix for a proposed redundancy
| Stage or decision | Legal or operational question | Evidence required | Employee or representative input | Owner and escalation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Operational case and job analysis | What has changed in operational requirements, and is a defined job no longer required to be performed by anyone? | Versioned business case; before-and-after duty and structure comparison; demand, cost or workflow data | Earlier involvement where required by the instrument, applicable WHS or OHS consultation duties, or established practice | Business owner; escalate to executive sponsor |
| Instrument and obligation map | Which award, agreement, contract, policy or sector obligations apply, and what does each require and when? | Coverage analysis per employee; extracted clauses; notice, severance and redeployment provisions | Representative arrangements identified where the instrument provides for them | Workplace-relations lead; escalate to legal advice where coverage is unclear |
| Consultation and alternatives | Has the required information been given promptly, and have views and alternatives been genuinely considered? | Written consultation material; meeting records; questions raised; responses given; changes made or reasons not | Employee and chosen representative views, alternatives and mitigation proposals | Line manager with people lead; escalate where substantive alternatives are proposed |
| Redeployment and selection | Would redeployment have been reasonable in all the circumstances, and is any pool selection lawful and evidenced? | Dated schedule of identified roles across the enterprise and associated entities; suitability assessment per employee; selection criteria, scoring and moderation | Employee preferences on location, hours, pay, status and retraining; response to roles offered or declined | People lead with hiring managers; escalate contested assessments to an unconflicted reviewer |
| Final decision, entitlements and close-out | Is the decision properly made and approved, are entitlements correctly calculated, and is the record coherent? | Approval record with reasons; notice and entitlement calculations; correspondence; complete indexed matter file | Opportunity to raise entitlement or calculation issues before final payment | Executive decision-maker; escalate to legal advice on transfer of business, insolvency or protected-absence issues |
Consultation in operation
Redeployment across the enterprise and associated entities
Pooled roles, selection and prohibited-reason safeguards
Entitlements, communications, privacy and implementation
Evidence architecture and governance review
Two worked examples
Where AWS assists, and when legal advice is required
A 12-step genuine-redundancy decision and evidence cycle
- Document the operational change and analyse the job — duties, responsibilities, reporting lines and time allocation before and after — rather than the title.
- Version and date the business case, recording the options considered and why the proposed approach was preferred.
- Map coverage for each affected employee: modern award, enterprise agreement, contract, policy, deed and any sector-specific obligation, extracting the operative clauses.
- Set the decision gates, naming who approves the organisational change and, separately, who approves any individual termination decision and when.
- Notify affected employees and any chosen representative promptly once the definite decision to introduce the change is made, with relevant information in writing.
- Consult on the introduction of the change, its effects and measures to avert or mitigate adverse effects, recording questions, alternatives and responses.
- Run a dated redeployment search across the enterprise and associated entities, listing identified roles and other work rather than asserting that none existed.
- Assess suitability for each affected employee against skills, pay, status, location, hours, caring circumstances, safety, retraining and their stated views, and record offers and responses.
- Where a pool exists, define it, set criteria in advance, assess against evidence, moderate across assessors and have contested outcomes reviewed by someone unconflicted.
- Calculate notice, redundancy pay where payable, accrued entitlements and any more generous instrument term, and check the payroll and tax treatment before the final conversation.
- Obtain final approval with recorded reasons, then communicate to affected employees before broader announcements, keeping consultation, outcome and workforce messaging distinct.
- Close the record: index the complete matter file, mark any retrospective note as such, apply access controls and retention, and run a short post-implementation review.
Frequently asked questions
- What makes a redundancy genuine under the Fair Work Act?
- Section 389 of the Fair Work Act 2009 has three practical parts. The employer no longer required the person's job to be performed by anyone because of changes in the operational requirements of the employer's enterprise; the employer complied with any obligation in an applicable modern award or enterprise agreement to consult about the redundancy; and it would not have been reasonable in all the circumstances to redeploy the person within the employer's enterprise or the enterprise of an associated entity. Whether those elements are made out depends entirely on the facts and the evidence.
- Can duties continue after a job is made redundant?
- Yes. The question is whether the job is still required to be performed by anyone, not whether every task has disappeared. Duties may be redistributed among remaining employees, absorbed into a broader role, automated or moved elsewhere, and the job can still be redundant. The opposite also applies: where a substantially similar job continues under a new title, with much the same duties, reporting line and skill requirements, the claim that the job is no longer required is difficult to sustain.
- Must consultation happen before any decision is made?
- Standard consultation terms are ordinarily enlivened once the employer has made a definite decision to introduce a major change, and then require discussion of the introduction of the change, its effects and measures to avert or mitigate adverse effects. That is a decision about the organisational change. Any decision to terminate a particular employee's employment should not be treated as settled before required consultation and redeployment consideration are complete. Check the wording of the applicable award or agreement, because obligations and timing vary.
- How far must an employer search for redeployment?
- The statutory question is whether redeployment would have been reasonable in all the circumstances within the employer's enterprise or the enterprise of an associated entity. In practice that means a dated search that identifies actual jobs, positions or other work — including upcoming vacancies, part-time and fixed-term work, and work currently performed by contractors or labour hire, including work that reasonable changes to workforce arrangements could make available. A general statement that no vacancies existed, without a schedule showing what was searched and when, carries little weight.
- Can an employee be required to compete for a redeployment role?
- Sometimes, but process design matters. Putting an affected employee through an ordinary open recruitment round for a role they could reasonably perform may weaken a redeployment case, particularly where the process operates as a hurdle rather than an assessment. Structured comparison is not always prohibited — where several affected employees seek one role, or a genuine capability gap exists, an evidenced comparative assessment may be appropriate. The reasoning and the evidence should be recorded either way.
- How should employees be selected when fewer similar roles remain?
- Define the pool on objective grounds, set criteria before assessment, use documented evidence rather than recollection, moderate across assessors and record who decided what and why. Current Fair Work Commission guidance indicates the selection process is not relevant to whether a dismissal was a case of genuine redundancy, but unlawful or discriminatory selection can support a general-protections or discrimination claim and can breach an instrument or policy. Stale performance impressions and undocumented judgments about fit are the common weaknesses.
- Does a small business always avoid redundancy pay?
- No. Small-business employer status is a defined question under the Fair Work Act rather than an impression of size, and it must be assessed on the facts at the relevant time. Even where a National Employment Standards exclusion applies, a modern award, enterprise agreement, contract or policy may provide a severance entitlement of its own. Minimum service and some employment types also affect the position. Check the applicable instrument and the current standards for each employee rather than applying a general rule.
- Does genuine redundancy prevent every kind of employment claim?
- No. Where the exclusion is established, an unfair-dismissal application cannot succeed because the dismissal falls outside that jurisdiction. It does not resolve a general-protections claim about the real reason for the decision, a discrimination complaint, a breach of an award, enterprise agreement, contract or policy, a failure to pay notice or entitlements, or work health and safety questions about how the change was managed. Build the process so those exposures are managed on their own terms.
Discuss this matter with AWS
Briefings can be scoped on a confidential basis. We respond within two business days.
Contact AWSRelated briefings
Workplace Advisory & Compliance
How to conduct a wage compliance review
An end-to-end guide for employers on governing, scoping, calculating, verifying and acting on a wage compliance review.
Read briefing →Workplace Advisory & Compliance
How to determine award coverage and classification
Coverage, application and classification are three separate questions, and job titles, salaries and payroll codes answer none of them. A step-by-step method for reaching a position you can stand behind.
Read briefing →Workplace Advisory & Compliance
Preparing for enterprise bargaining: an employer's roadmap
Making a single-enterprise agreement is a statutory process with fixed steps and deadlines. This roadmap follows the pathway from scoping and notification time through to approval and payroll implementation.
Read briefing →